Published by Wikileaks & Bivol.bg
date: 9/19/2005 14:14 refid: 05SOFIA1618 origin: Embassy Sofia classification: SECRET destination: 05SOFIA1598 header: This record is a partial extract of the original cable. The full text of the original cable is not available. S E C R E T SECTION 01 OF 02 SOFIA 001618 SIPDIS E.O. 12958: DECL: 09/16/2015 TAGS: PREL, PGOV, ASEC, KCRM, PINR, BG SUBJECT: BULGARIAN INTERIOR MINISTER DEFENDS CONTROVERSIAL APPOINTMENTS, CALLS FOR FORMAL AGREEMENT ON COOPERATION REF: SOFIA 1598 Classified By: Amb John Beyrle, reasons 1.5(b) and (d). 1. (S) SUMMARY. Interior Minister Rumen Petkov argued in his first meeting with Ambassador Beyrle for both deeper and more formal cooperation on intelligence and law enforcement matters. He called for the signing of a Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (MLAT) or a memorandum of understanding on law enforcement cooperation. One or the other is necessary to bring the current level of bilateral information sharing into conformity with Bulgarian law, according to Petkov. The Interior Minister defended vigorously his decision to appoint a 13-member "advisory council" consisting largely of former members of the Communist-era intelligence services, saying that the council would act only as a "transmission belt" between the Ministry and the interested public. Petkov summarized the draft legislation to reorganize the MoI, and previewed personnel changes, including the replacement of Chief Secretary Boiko Borisov by current intelligence-service (NSS) director Ivan Chubanov. Chubanov subsequently turned down the appointment. Ambassador emphasized the need for strong cooperation in the fight against terrorism and cross-border crime. END SUMMARY 2. (S) Amb Beyrle used the occasion of his September 14 courtesy call on newly-appointed Minister of Interior Rumen Petkov to thank Petkov for the Bulgarian intelligence services' contribution to the global war on terrorism. Cooperation with the previous government in this area had been outstanding, and we would like to continue our joint efforts against terrorism and proliferation of WMD. He noted that a team would be coming out from Washington the week of September 19 to discuss precisely these issues. On the law enforcement side, organized crime, drug trafficking and trafficking in persons could only be countered through joint efforts. PETKOV WANTS A TREATY, OR AT LEAST AN MOU ----------------------------------------- 3. (C) Petkov began by noting that Bulgaria considers the U.S. "a strategic partner." Personnel changes in the Ministry, including the planned promotion of General Chubanov to Chief Secretary and his replacement at NSS by Colonel Ivan Drashkov, would reflect this partnership. Both men are highly regarded by their American counterparts, according to Petkov. However, in addition to personal relationships, it is important to strengthen the formal relationship. Petkov proposed in this context the signing of bilateral agreements such as an MLAT or MOU on law enforcement cooperation, strongly implying that the current level of informal cooperation, at least on law enforcement matters, could not continue without some sort of formal agreement on sharing classified information. (When the MoI raised this issue last fall, deputy Minister Boiko Kotsev -- who retains his position under Petkov -- said the existing agreement on sharing of military information was not sufficient under Bulgarian law to cover bilateral law enforcement cooperation.) ADVISORY COUNCIL: A ROGUES' GALLERY FROM THE PAST? --------------------------------------------- ----- 4. (C) The day before his meeting with Beyrle, Petkov announced that he was appointing an advisory council of former high-ranking intelligence and law enforcement officials. The 13-member "Citizens Advisory Council" includes leading figures from the so-called Generals' Movement, a BSP faction launched in 1998 by leading figures from the Communist-era intelligence service (First State Security Directorate) and political police (Sixth State Security Directorate) with strong ties to Russian business. The Movement arose as an internal opposition within the BSP against the reformist leadership of then-Chairman -- and now Bulgarian President -- Georgi Purvanov. Although the Generals' influence has waned in recent years, they still remain a factor in the BSP, mostly because of their business and financial ties, and because of their knowledge of information contained in the security-service archives. The founder and informal leader of the Movement, 75 year-old Gen. Lyuben Gotsev, and one of its more notorious members, Gen. Brigo Asparukhov, are on the MoI advisory council. 5. (C) Petkov defended the council, saying that the members would have no access to classified information and no role in the Ministry's operations. Publicly, he has said that the council will increase the efficiency and transparency of the MoI. Privately, he was dismissive of Gotsev and company, saying, "These old frauds just meet every Tuesday to gossip." He told Beyrle that the council will act as the Ministry's "transmission belt" in explaining to both the public and the MoI's more than 60,000 employees the changes envisioned under the new Interior Ministry Act. "Every one of them is colorful in his own way, and they are influential with journalists," Petkov said, "but they are far removed from reality." RESTRUCTURING THE MINISTRY -------------------------- 6. (C) Petkov said that his most difficult task as minister will be implementing the draft Ministry of Interior Act, proposed by the previous government and soon to be considered by parliament. The act introduces major changes in the structure of the Ministry, the status of its employees, and the balance between the political and professional leadership. Perhaps most controversial is the consolidation of the six existing law enforcement, intelligence and fire-fighting agencies into three, and their direct subordination to the minister. The role of the Chief Secretary -- traditionally the Ministry's highest-ranking SIPDIS professional -- is correspondingly reduced. Far less interesting to the public and the press, but of direct concern to the Ministry's more than 60,000 employees, are the law's efforts to bring order, transparency and predictability to the MoI personnel system. A major challenge for the MoI's institutional culture will be its "de-militarization," in accordance with European Union practice. Instead of military titles, officers will carry the ranks of commissioners, inspectors, etc. Petkov hopes to convince the old Generals on his advisory council to support the changes. 7. (C) Petkov insisted that the new structure will result in better coordination by consolidating the four existing police services -- regular police, gendarmerie, border police, and the National Service for Combating Organized Crime -- in a single police directorate reporting directly to the ministry's political leadership. He promised that, under his leadership, the police would work closely with prosecutors to investigate the spate of high-profile gangland killings that have plagued Bulgaria. He also promised to take decisive action against police officers who "cross the line" in their dealings with criminals. In response to the Beyrle's offer of assistance in the fight against terrorist financing and money laundering, Petkov said that he hoped the Financial Intelligence Agency, currently under the Ministry of Finance, would be moved to the Ministry of Interior. COMMENT ------- 8. (S) Though only 43, Petkov is in some ways an old thinker. His desire to sign formal agreements, whether or not they will have any real operational impact, as well as his reference to the advisory council as a "transmission belt" for influencing the public, hark back to communist days. Nevertheless, Petkov seems to be a pragmatist. His choices to replace Borisov and head the NSS are both individuals with proven track records of close cooperation with the U.S., especially on intelligence matters. The choice of members for his advisory council, however, indicate that Petkov has a tin ear for public relations and perhaps a real weakness for old communists and "Red businessmen." Reactions to the appointments range from outrage and cries of "I-told-you-so" on the Right, to sheepish embarrassment among members of the governing coalition. Petkov also seems sincere about reforming the Ministry and making it run more efficiently, but again there is controversy over whether the balance of power will tilt too far toward the MoI's political leadership, leaving the professionals subject to undue influence. One thing, however, is clear: for better or worse, Petkov will be far more active than his somnambulant predecessor in personally running the Ministry. BEYRLE
